Gnu public license is all but free and you should never use it. With open source software, there are two main types of licenses. Also i read that if an application is under gpl license you can. In this case you would be redistributing pyqt which you can do. Taking a closer look at microsofts mspl open source license. Since mysql is running exclusively on the isp computer, this application is considered internal. The people to whom you sold copies of gpl software are just as free as you are to make copies and sell them for whatever price they feel is right, including a price equal to zero. As a practical matter, you can t sell what you dont have in the first place. How are cloud vendors able to sell mysql as a service if it. Does all gnu software use the gnu gpl as its license. You can run, change, ship, and commercialize the distribution of software licensed under. Selling free software gnu project free software foundation. Openoffice, for example, is distributed under the apache license.
It is possible to do something like this, by releasing the software under two different licenses, but qgis doesnt do that. Finally, mysql license can be used free of charge for all projects that themselves run under the gpl or comparable free license. In 1965, adr developed the first licensed software product independent of a. As a practical matter, therefore, distribution of the software under.
Selling the software is actually not against the rules in the slightest bit. You need a commercial license if you want to modify mysql and redistribute the result as nonfree software. Not all of the users and developers of free software agreed with the goals of the free software. What license or licenses are you using for the mono project. How are cloud vendors able to sell mysql as a service if it has gpl license. This license is aimed at giving and protecting all users unlimited freedom to use, study, and privately modify the software, and if the user adheres to the terms and conditions of the gpl, freedom to redistribute. I sell the software, but i also keep it open source under the mit license. Yes you can sell it in both cases, but for gpl you need to provide the source code for the gpl parts as well as the code you have written your self. The mono runtime, compilers and tools and most of the class libraries are licensed under the mit license. Blender is released under the gnu general public license gpl, or free software. How should i apply the apache license to my own software. I create a game using software that is published under the gnu license, such as codeblocks, the mingw compiler, etc.
Is the apache license compatible with the gpl gnu public license. The gpl thus minimizes the number of programs that can be built using a gpled standard. May 12, 2015 if you sell a software under gnu gpl 3. Except for one special situation, the gnu general public license gnu gpl has no requirements about how much you can. However, free here does not essentially mean freewareit can also be a paid software. Can i use gpl libraries in a closed source project if only the output is distributed. You asked two questions, and they both have simple answers. It does not prevent the sale of derivative software or its inclusion in commercial products.
The licenses were originally written by richard stallman, former head of the free software foundation fsf, for the gnu project, and grant the recipients of a computer program the rights of the free software. On selling exceptions to the gnu gpl free software. Thus, patent rights give a patentee great control over who uses his invention. If a developer modifies a program released under the gpl, he is expected to release the modified program under the same. At the same time, in and by themselves, licenses cant protect you from certain abuses. Why the gpl is incompatible with commercial software. Gnu general public license simple english wikipedia, the. This license lets the user of the software use a program in many of the same ways as if it were public domain. However, is it legally acceptable to try and patent a piece of software if that software uses a bsd licensed open source file as library or support code. Can you take an open source software, modify it and sell. Why you should use a bsd style license for your open. Id like to know if the following situation is legal. In fact, as we argued in previous posts, open source software may.
Basically, it allows users to legally copy, distribute and modify software. Just remember that the original code is still covered by the apache license and you must comply with its terms. Aug 26, 2008 sflc continues to conduct gpl enforcement and compliance efforts for many of its clients who release their software under the gpl, the gnu lesser public license lgpl and other copyleft licenses. A short guide to open source licenses smashing magazine.
Some views on the ideas of selling exceptions to free software licenses, such as the gnu gpl are also available many people believe that the spirit of the gnu project is that you should not charge money for distributing copies of software, or that you should charge as little as possiblejust enough to cover the cost. Technically, your software is free, however you could in effect bundle the software with a service that results in you. If you have developed a new free email client for linux, say. Gpl ive already written about why the gpl can be a dangerous license. Can i sell my mitlicensed software if it is modified by. I took this as an indicator that open source was the way to go, so i started distributing my own work under similar licenses.
Can you make profit with software under the gnu license. However, the secret formula for software is the source code and the gpl requires that any software licensed under the gpl be accompanied by a copy of the source code. Bsdlicensed code can be sold or included in proprietary products without. You can use any gpld software for commercial gain in general, too, of. An example of a copyleft free software license is the often used gnu general public license gpl, also the first copyleft license. In all cases, the exact requirements are determined by the applicable license. It was written by richard stallman of free software foundation for gnu project. Selling free software some views on the ideas of selling exceptions to free software licenses, such as the gnu gpl are also available.
Both the binary and the source code becomes gpl so anyone else can get a copy from you, sell. Frequently asked questions about the gnu licenses gnu project. Frequently asked questions about the gnu licenses gnu. The gnu lesser general public license lgpl is a free software license published by the free software foundation fsf. If you receive software under an open source license, you can always use that software for commercial purposes, but that doesnt always mean you can place further restrictions on people who receive the software from you. Nov 02, 2016 gpl, or the gnu general public license, is an open source license meant for software. Can software licensed under gnu general public license v3.
Someone forks my repository and makes some great improvements to my software. Furthermore, am i allowed to make money from ad revenue. You can give the software under it for free, or sell. With free software, users dont have to pay the distribution fee in order to use the. A transaction process that is transparent for all concerned and that, of course, directly involves the software. How on earth could you make sure that your software can be used with something that doesnt necessarily exist yet. This article by jerry epplin sheds some light on the issues associated with using gpl software in embedded applications, and. Taking a closer look at microsofts mspl open source license by deeann. The gpl doesnt require you to gpl license all the software in your company. The emacs general public license, a february 1988 version, a direct predecessor of the gnu gpl. You can sell it but you have to change the license of your software to the gpl also, it seems nuts that you must change your license, regardless of the size of the code you. I personally dont see why you can t do both as long as you make the source available for the gpl things youre using.
Can i use gpl libraries in a closed source project if only. It only says that whoever you give the software too must also receive the source code and the same rights. Because the gpl requires that other software with parts of licensed code to also be licensed under. They couldnt do it, even if those were good things. The interpreted program, to the interpreter, is just data. Can i sell an application under the gnu affero general public license gpl. Developers can omit it when licensing their software.
Can i sell my pyqt4app without having a pyqt license. This article by jerry epplin sheds some light on the issues associated with using gpl software in embedded applications, and attempts to dispel the. If you use gpl source code in your software, then by accepting the gpl license of that third party source code you must agree to license your software under the same terms. Sflc continues to conduct gpl enforcement and compliance efforts for many of its clients who release their software under the gpl, the gnu lesser public license lgpl and other copyleft licenses. A practical guide to gpl compliance software freedom law. In contrast, the basic idea behind distributing software under an open source license is that anyone should be able to view and use the source code of the. So you can adapt that software for other customers and sell it to them as well. By contrast, the gnu general public license is intended to guarantee your freedom to share and change all versions of a programto make sure it remains free software for all its users.
The same general conditions apply to other popular foss licenses. Not asking if one can patent the open source bsd licensed portion rather the unique software that was written on top of the open source. Yes, the gpl license allows users to sell the original as well as the modified software. Why you should use a bsd style license for your open source. Gpl is the acronym for gnus general public license, and its one of the most popular open source licenses. First, many licensors do not know what rights they have to re sell. The gnu general public license gnu gpl or gpl is a series of widely used free software licenses that guarantee end users the freedom to run, study, share, and modify the software. Drm software not drmcrack software written under gpl any drm system released under the gpl or containing gpl software can be circumvented by a program.
The gnu general public licence gpl is probably one of the most commonly used licenses for opensource projects. Can i write commercial or proprietary applications that run with mono. The apache license is a permissive open source software license so you can release your modified version of the apache licensed product under any license of your choice. Except for one special situation, the gnu general public license gnu gpl has no requirements about how much you can charge for distributing a copy of free software. The implication is that gpled software is not necessarily free from cost, and therefore you can in fact license your programs under the gpl and still sell them for money. This license allows software to be freely used, modified, and redistributed by anyone. Selling exceptions depends fundamentally on using a copyleft license, such as the gnu gpl, for the free software release. Mar 05, 2001 using gpl software in embedded applications. Nov 19, 20 marco fioretti answers a techrepublic members questions about charging fees for software thats made available under the gnu gpl license version 2 or 3. Some modules we make are using more permissive licenses, though, for example, the blender cycles rendering engine is available as apache 2. In doing so, we have found that most violations stem from a few common mistakes that can be, for the most part, easily avoided.
You can distribute your application using a gpl library commercially, but you must also provide the source code. Whether its bsd or gpl, you can sell it, because you own it presuming, of course, that you actually wrote it yourself. Yes, the gpl is completely compatible with the notion. But the licence itself does not refrain you to sell the software. If your software is licensed under the terms of the gpl, it is free. Can gpl licenced software be used in corporate environments. Can someone take a software under the gpl license, modify it and sell it in download form via the internet as. During the 1980s, we developed most of the essential components of the system and designed the gnu general public license gnu gpl to release them under a license designed specifically to protect freedom for all users of a program. Can i then clone their repository, and sell the improved software without sharing any profits. Ive covered the common questions that crop up when discussing secondhand software if you have any others or have anything to correct or add please give me a shout. Software freedom as intended by richard stallman and the fsf is.
You can give your modified code away for free, or sell it, or keep it to yourself, or whatever you like. Explaining and understanding the gnu general public license. If i use a piece of software that has been obtained under the gnu gpl, am i allowed to. However, note that commercial is not the same as proprietary. Gpl or general public license, sometimes also called gnu gpl, is the most commonly used free software license.
For example, if a resale licensee tries to sell private label master resale rights, the scope of the license exceeds what the licensee actually owns and can legitimately sell. That means that blender can be used commercially by artists, by studios to make animation films or. May i license my own software under the apache license. You can run it on any data interpreted program, any way you like, and there are no requirements about licensing. That means you are free to download, reuse, modify, and distribute any files hosted in s git repositories under.
So if you have to buy a commercial license for things the gpl doesnt permit, what are those. The source code for the arduino environment is covered by the gpl, which requires any modifications to be opensourced under the same license. Most would not unless theres more than just software. I mean, that is the whole reason i do open source in the first place. Can gnu licensed software be used for commercial gain. Can gnu licensed software be used for commercial gain without. We, the free software foundation, use the gnu general public license for most of our software. Outofuse or never used software licenses amount to dead capital that, however, can be activated rapidly and easily by selling to relicense. The first is called the gnu general public license the gpl. Can gnu licensed software be used for commercial gain without selling the software. In doing so, we have found that most violations stem from a few common mistakes that can.
Gpl software allows you to redistribute something as long as you provide it under the same license. For those who must work with staticallylinked implementations of multiple software standards, the gpl is often a poor license, because it precludes using proprietary implementations of the standards. It can also be read as a bsd versus gpl open source license. Developing software under gplv3 and selling the source code. One of the main idea behind the gpl is that the user must be able to modify or audit software. Why dash uses the mit license and not a copyleft gpl. Home blog whitesource top 10 gpl license questions answered. Feb 25, 2006 advocates of the gnu general public license gnu gpl like to perpetuate the idea that programs released under it are free as in speech, not free as in beer. The license allows developers and companies to use and integrate a software component released under the lgpl into their own even proprietary software without being required by the terms of a strong copyleft license.
For distributed elements of saas and cloud systems like javascript or distributed software including mobile apps and beta tests, you can use software under permissive licenses, but you will need to be especially careful before using software under copyleft licenses. A practical guide to gpl compliance software freedom law center. The restrictions they typically impose are 1 attribution so if they sell the software they typically have to say that you are the original author in some way and 2 licensing e. Under a gpl v3 license, can i take pieces of an open source. Likewise, an internet service provider may make mysql available to its customers without having to pay mysql license fees. The gpl grants and guarantees a wide range of rights to developers who work on opensource projects. I have used this text data and created a ios product. Top 10 gnu gpl license questions answered whitesource. The question is, why would someone buy it, if presumably, they can get it for free. The gnu general public license gpl is a computer software copyleft license.
Drupal, and all contributed files that are derivative works of drupal hosted on, are licensed under the gnu general public license, version 2 or later. The gpl the gnu general public license the most popular copyleft licence, sometimes gets a hostile press, often for reasons that. May 26, 2014 however, just to be sure, if i am hosting a gpl or mit software and the end user only use the website, i am not distributing it, right. Many people believe that the spirit of the gnu project is that you should not charge money for distributing copies of software. When are you required to have a commercial mysql license. I surely can modify some lgpl lib so that your software doesnt work with it. Under the gpl, while you can sell it, theres really no point in buying it. You may copy, distribute and modify the software as long as you track changesdates of in source files and keep modifications under gpl. I have some text data that is under the license terms of gpl. A copyleft license permits embedding in a larger program only if the whole combined program is released under that license. If a license does not permit users to make copies and sell them, it is a nonfree. But the gpl never says that you have to post source code publicly. Frequently answered questions open source initiative. The licensing scheme is planned to allow proprietary developers to write applications with mono.
The difference is that with bsd, if you ever release the source code and if you didnt, who cares what license you use on it inhouse. Under a gpl v3 license, can i take pieces of an open. This question regards the gpl license for open source software. You can t resell oem licenses because they are tied to a specific machine. I am using ghostscript on a desktop application that i intend to sell online. Marco fioretti answers a techrepublic members questions about charging fees for software thats made available under the gnu gpl license version 2 or 3. How does the gpl affect the licensing and selling of software. You can freely use, modify, distribute and sell a software licensed under the apache license without worrying about the use of software. Permission is hereby granted, free of charge, to any person obtaining a copy of this software and associated documentation files the software, to deal in the software without restriction, including without limitation the rights to use, copy, modify, merge, publish, distribute, sublicense, andor sell copies of the software. Do i have to publish my code, if yes, can i publish it under an ambiguous name so no one can see it under gpl or mit license, can i hire developers to work with my private github repo. Difference between different types of open sources licenses. See this page from the fsf on selling gpl software. This document makes a case for using a bsd style license for software and data.
6 1019 1372 669 90 1115 646 1003 1565 938 618 665 857 917 69 1199 1259 61 1457 857 1261 1283 443 400 1152 470 1142 956 63 452 194 1499 1064 377